Mon 18 May 2009
Measuring Success with Web 2.0 Tools
Posted by Shamsha_Damani under Uncategorized
Web 2.0 is the craze these days. We like to keep up with the latest tools and toys and try to use them in our professional lives. But how do you measure the impact of your hard work? This is something that I struggle with so I signed up for this roundtable sharing session: “Measuring Success with Web 2.0 Tools.†We talked about blogs, wikis, Twitter, Facebook, Delicious, Yahoo Pipes, and many others. I was amazed at some of the work these librarians were doing, especially with Yahoo Pipes. However, we had one common gripe: we can’t get our people (staff and/or patrons) to use these tools. I think most of us are still at the implementation stage; measuring the impact of web 2.0 is not really on our radar yet. But this discussion proved that we need to think about implementation and impact simultaneously.
When I created a Twitter account for my library not too long ago, measuring impact was not something I thought about a lot. I figured having a reasonable number of followers would indicate success. However, for those of you who are on Twitter, you know that amassing a huge following doesn’t mean that you’ve somehow made it. It is the interactions that count. But how do you measure such interactions on Twitter? By the number of retweets? By the number of direct replies? By the number of direct messages? All valid questions I should’ve asked before I created the account!
There are too many dead blogs, abandoned Twitter accounts, and unfinished wikis by librarians. We have good intentions but get frustrated when others don’t share our enthusiasm for web 2.0 tools. I think that having an end goal in mind is a good start (sounds contradictory, I know!) So the question to ask your boss (or yourself!) is not whether you can/should have X (Twitter, Facebook, YouTube, etc), but how will having X impact your library’s bottom line!
Shamsha
P.S. If you guys have some success stories about web 2.0 implementation or impact, please do share!
6 Responses to “ Measuring Success with Web 2.0 Tools ”
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 36
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 36
Comments:
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 133
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 133
Trackbacks & Pingbacks:
-
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 141
Pingback from Measuring Success with Web 2.0 Tools » Official MLA 2009 Blog « MyPage Builder
May 18th, 2009 at 12:57 pm[...] more from the original source: Measuring Success with Web 2.0 Tools » Official MLA 2009 Blog [...]
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 133
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 133
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 133
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 133
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 133
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 133
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 133
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 133
May 18th, 2009 at 4:26 am
I was thinking in exactly the same lines actually. How do you actually measure impact using web 2.0 tools?
http://librariesusingevidence.blogspot.com/2007/12/eblip-and-library-20-friends-or-foe.html talks about the possible conflict between library 2.0 and evidence based librarian
Recently I started to study Library twitter accounts see
http://ow.ly/5JKO for a list of almost 500 accounts, the obvious thing I grabbed was number of followers.
I also studied follower/following ratios, date of first twit, and various powerful tools like twitstats, twitanalyzer etc allowed one to pull as many types of statistics as you wanted.
From signal to noise ratios, percentage of mentions, percentage of retwits , velocity, reach (number of 2nd generation followers) and more.. Tons of complicated systems claimed to measure \influence\ etc.
Other interesting questions I investigated/ am investigating
1. What are the typical spread of the follower/following ratio for libraries? Below 1? , round 1? above 1? Or were they following anyone at all? If so how did they decide who to follow?
2. Was it true that libraries with low ratios (high number of following compared to followers), was correlated with more followers (my analysis of 450 library accounts says the opposite is true)
3. Were libraries getting many queries via twitter? (% of @s at them, answer not very high).
4. How fast was the typical library response to a query over twitter? Was it treated like an email query? or a IM?
5. What was the average age of a library twitter account? Was age correlated with size of following?
6. What was the distribution of twits per week? How many were twiting using automated methods (twitter feed, friendfeed etc) as opposed to manually? IS it true that automated accounts generally led to less interaction with users because users perceived that the light was on but no one was home?
I’m still halfway still my analysis, but so far the results which is quite messy can be found
http://musingsaboutlibrarianship.blogspot.com/2009/05/library-twitter-league-official-library.html
http://musingsaboutlibrarianship.blogspot.com/2009/05/are-public-libraries-really-more.html
http://musingsaboutlibrarianship.blogspot.com/2009/05/managing-twitter-accounts-for-libraries.html
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 36
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 36
May 18th, 2009 at 8:29 pm
Thanks Aaron. Twitter is new to a lot of folks and we are still testing the waters. I think that institutions that use Twitter are probably asking themselves similar questions about impact and trying to figure out a way to measure success (or failure!). Thanks for your insightful comments!
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 36
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 36
May 18th, 2009 at 9:12 pm
Shamsha,
I think it is great you are even working with web2.0 in your workplace. I am still struggling with getting people to see the benefits of and use RSS; therefore, using other web2.0 tools is very difficult. I would like to hear some success stories and some failures, just to see why something didn’t work.
For instance, I started a wiki on my library website. I did it when I first started my job thinking everyone would want to participate in a wiki and add to the resources I put out there. I found out very quickly this was not the case. The wiki failed for several reasons: 1) Time (my time to update and the staff’s time to update or read); 2.) Lack of interest 3.) Poor marketing.
These are just some of the reason it did not succeed. I think the main problem is I jumped onto the band wagon too quickly and did not think through all the issues. I quickly realized a wiki in my setting was not feasible and started focusing my attentions elsewhere. I now have a dead wiki on my website which I do not want to take down because it lists some wonderful resources. I know eventually, I will have to remove it when I overhaul the website again!
Thank you for posting about your experience at MLA!
Alisha
http://alisha764.wordpress.com/
Twitter: Alisha764
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 36
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 36
May 19th, 2009 at 6:21 pm
Thank you Alisha for sharing your experience. I am keen on introducing web 2.0 tools in my workplace and would like to be realistic. I have thought about a wiki but I may have more success setting up a blog and highlighting relevant articles as my colleagues are not looking at the rss feeds that I set up for them.
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 36
Deprecated: Function ereg() is deprecated in /chao/mlanpc/public_html/mla09/wp-content/themes/connections-reloaded-2/comments.php on line 36
September 21st, 2009 at 8:01 pm
Hi,
can someone provide me a measurement tool to gauge the knowledge of librarians with Library/ Web 2.0? Thanks